FYI: I have had this mascara in black and brown, waterproof and regular.
Cons: #1: I know there has been a ton of hype about the new rubber bristle brushes, but I have to say that I don't care for this one. I have super long lashes already and was just looking for volume, but the brush made all my lashes clump together. Awful!
#2: This stuff is hard to get off. Even with eye makeup remover, it is still there under my eyes the next day.
Pros: #1: It truly is a sumdgeproof mascara. Flaking is not a big problem and the flakes don't smudge.
#2: If you use a disposable mascara wand with not a lot of product on it, the formula will go on beautifully, without clumping and will keep lashes curled! One of few mascaras that can do that.
#3: Also, the black brown formula is very dark brown, which I enjoy.
3 out of 5 stars. It's okay, nothing miraculous.
Would I purchase again? I probably wouldn't purchase it again, just because I think there are better drugstore mascaras than this one.
